Skip to main content

Crime and Punishment by R.K.Narayan

"Sitare Zameen Par" & R. K. Narayan: Reflections on Education, Empathy & Responsibility






This reflective blog has been written as part of an academic task given by Megha Ma’am, encouraging us to explore how stories and films shape our understanding of education, childhood, and adult responsibility. After studying R. K. Narayan’s short story Crime and Punishment   which subtly critiques modern parenting and the struggles of teachers  we were asked to watch the film Sitaare Zameen Par (2025) in theatres. This blog presents my reflections on how the film and the story portray the education system, the roles of teachers and parents, and what important life lessons we can take away from both.



  1. How does the movie portray the education system?
In Sitaare Zameen Par, the Indian education system is portrayed as rigid, competitive, and often blind to individual needs especially those of children with intellectual disabilities. The protagonist Gulshan, a disgraced basketball coach, is initially dismissive of the players he’s forced to train young people with cognitive impairments. However, the film evolves to critique a system that measures every child with the same academic or performance yardstick, offering no space for different kinds of intelligence.

In contrast, R. K. Narayan’s story shows a private tutoring environment, where the teacher is overwhelmed by a spoiled, manipulative child, pampered by overprotective parents. The system here is not rigid, but too indulgent, ignoring discipline entirely in favor of psychological theories. Ironically, both portrayals show how extremes in educational approaches too harsh or too lenient fail the child.

2. What message does the movie give about the role of teachers and parents?

Both the film and the story dive deep into the complicated roles of adults in shaping young lives.

In Sitaare Zameen Par, the transformation of Gulshan from a cynical coach to an empathetic mentor is inspiring. He learns that being a good teacher is not about enforcing rules or achieving results, but about listening, understanding, and nurturing potential. The children, once labeled “incapable,” begin to thrive under his belief in them. The film makes a powerful statement: a teacher’s kindness can be the turning point in a child's life.

In contrast, Narayan’s story paints a more cynical picture. The teacher here is exhausted, underpaid, and emotionally blackmailed by the child. The parents, with their fancy theories, deny any structure or consequence, and the child, lacking both respect and direction, becomes manipulative. While humorous, it also warns us: when parents refuse to acknowledge reality and teachers are stripped of authority, children suffer most.

3. How does it compare with the story?

Comparing the Two: Mirror Images with a Message

What’s fascinating is how Sitaare Zameen Par and Crime and Punishment complement each other. One is a heartwarming tale of growth and acceptance, the other a satirical warning about misguided parenting and emotional neglect.
  • The movie moves from cynicism to hope.
  • The story moves from hope to exhaustion. 
Both emphasize that education is not just about subjects but about shaping human beings, and that teachers need support not pressure or interference from parents.

4.What did you feel or learn after watching the movie?

My Takeaway: More Than a Movie or a Story

Watching Sitaare Zameen Par left me emotional and thoughtful. It wasn’t just about inclusion, or basketball, or disability it was about respecting every human being’s journey. I was reminded that real teaching happens when we stop trying to "fix" children and start trying to understand them.

From R. K. Narayan’s story, I learned how adult ego and parental delusion can trap a child in unhealthy dynamics. From the movie, I learned how love, patience, and empathy can break that trap.

Final Thoughts

Both works, in their own unique way, ask us to rethink education. Whether it’s a child with learning disabilities or one with too much freedom, the message is clear:
We must create safe, supportive spaces where children are allowed to grow  not pressured to perform or pampered into dysfunction.

❝ Every child is a star on earth , if only we look closely enough to see them shine. ❞

Reference:

R. S. Prasanna, director. Sitaare Zameen Par. 2025. Aamir Khan Productions, 2025. 

THANK YOU  

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"One-Eyed" by Meena Kandasamy

Group Assignment on "One-Eyed" by Meena Kandasamy Given by: Prakruti Ma’am Group Members: Leader: Nirali Vaghela Members: Nikita Vala, Kumkum Hirani, Khushi Makwana, Krishna Baraiya , Tanvi Mehra 1.Which poem and questions were discussed by the group? Our group discussed the poem “One-Eyed” by Meena Kandasamy, which powerfully portrays caste-based discrimination in Indian society through the experience of a young girl named Dhanam. We discussed the following two questions as part of our assigned task: Long Answer: What kind of treatment is given to the untouchables? Discuss with reference to the poem “One-Eyed.” Short Answer: What does the “one-eyed” symbolize in the poem?     1. Long Answer Q: What kind of treatment is given to the untouchables? Discuss with reference to “One-Eyed” by Meena Kandasamy. In Meena Kandasamy’s poem One-Eyed, the treatment of untouchables is shown as deeply cruel, inhumane, and unjust. Through a single incident  where a young girl named...
Post a Comment
Read more

MAHARAJA (2024)

  FILM STUDIES WORKSHEET: MAHARAJA (2024) Introduction: In contemporary Tamil cinema, Maharaja (2024), directed by Nithilan Saminathan, stands out as a masterclass in editing and non-linear storytelling. The film invites viewers into a layered narrative where time folds and unfolds, revealing truths in fragments. This blog explores how editing techniques shape the narrative structure and emotional resonance of Maharaja, based on a film studies worksheet designed by Dr. Dilipsir Barad.  (Click Here)  Analysing Editing & Non-Linear Narrative   PART A: BEFORE WATCHING THE FILM   What is non-linear narration in cinema? Non-linear narration is a storytelling method where events are presented out of chronological sequence. Instead of moving directly from beginning to end, the narrative jumps between past, present, and future. This technique can enhance suspense, deepen character exploration, and reveal information strategically.   Example: In Maharaja (2024),...
Post a Comment
Read more

Lab Session: DH s- AI Bias NotebookLM Activity

  Lab Session: DH s:  AI Bias NotebookLM Activity - This blog is about the lab activity in which we had to explore the AI Bias Notebook and Language Model (LM) activity, experiment with prompts, and analyze the outputs for bias. This task was assigned by Dilip Barad sir. NotebookLM   Bias in AI and Literary Interpretation: The source material provides a transcript from a faculty development program session organized by SRM University - Sikkim, focusing on bias in Artificial Intelligence (AI) models and its implications for literary interpretation. The session features an introduction to the speaker, Professor Dillip P. Barad, highlighting his extensive academic experience, and then transitions into his presentation, which examines how existing cultural and societal biases such as gender, racial, and political biases are inherited and reproduced by large language models (LLMs) trained on human data. Professor Barad uses critical literary theories (feminism, postcolonialism...
Post a Comment
Read more