War poetry

This blog is part of task given by prakrutima'am

Choose one poem from the English literary cannon which deals with the theme of war and compare it with any one of the five war poems you have studied in this unit. [Discuss aspects like the style of the poems, language employed, treatment of the theme of war, etc.] How are they different? Are there any similarities?

To address this prompt, we will compare "Dulce et Decorum Est" by Wilfred Owen, a renowned war poem from World War I, with "The Charge of the Light Brigade" by Alfred Lord Tennyson, a Victorian-era poem inspired by the Crimean War.

Comparison

1. Theme and Treatment of War

"The Charge of the Light Brigade":

Tennyson’s poem celebrates the bravery and valor of soldiers despite the futility of their mission. War is depicted as honorable, and the soldiers are remembered as heroic figures. The tone is reverential, reflecting Victorian ideals of duty and sacrifice.

"Dulce et Decorum Est":

Owen challenges the glorification of war, highlighting its brutality and the physical and emotional toll on soldiers. His poem deconstructs the patriotic ideal expressed in the Latin phrase "Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori" (It is sweet and proper to die for one’s country), branding it "The old Lie."

2. Style and Structure

Tennyson:

Written in dactylic dimeter, the rhythmic pattern mimics the galloping horses, creating a sense of urgency. The poem uses repetition (“Half a league, half a league”) and vivid imagery (“Into the valley of Death”) to dramatize the battle.

Owen:

The poem employs irregular rhythm and structure to reflect the chaos of war. Owen’s use of vivid imagery and shocking realism (“guttering, choking, drowning”) immerses the reader in the soldiers’ harrowing experiences.

3. Language and Imagery

Tennyson:

Uses elevated, heroic language with metaphors and allusions (“Theirs not to reason why, / Theirs but to do and die”) to highlight the soldiers' obedience and valor. Death is presented abstractly, without focusing on its horrors.

Owen:

Employs graphic, visceral imagery to convey the agony of war (“the blood / Come gargling from the froth-corrupted lungs”). His language is raw and unflinching, aiming to evoke a sense of horror and empathy.

4. Perspective and Tone

Tennyson:

Written from the perspective of an observer, the tone is patriotic and awe-inspired, focusing on collective heroism.

Owen:

Written from a soldier’s perspective, the tone is bitter and disillusioned, critiquing the romanticized view of war perpetuated by earlier poets like Tennyson.

Differences

Tennyson idealizes war and focuses on heroism, while Owen exposes its grim realities.

The structure of Tennyson’s poem is regular and rhythmic, while Owen’s is fragmented and chaotic.

Tennyson's tone is celebratory, whereas Owen's is critical and somber.

Similarities

Both poems highlight the sacrifice of soldiers.

Both employ vivid imagery to capture the experience of war.

Each poem reflects its historical context and societal attitudes toward war.

Conclusion

While Tennyson's poem aligns with the Victorian glorification of war, Owen's work is a modernist critique of the same. Together, these poems offer contrasting perspectives, showcasing how attitudes toward war evolved over time.

"War poetry is not necessarily ‘anti-war’. It is, however, about the very large questions of life: identity, innocence, guilt, loyalty, courage, compassion, humanity, duty, desire, death." Discuss this statement in the context of any two of the war poems you have studied.

This statement encapsulates the essence of war poetry, emphasizing its engagement with profound existential questions rather than simply advocating for or against war. To explore this, we will examine "Dulce et Decorum Est" by Wilfred Owen and "The Soldier" by Rupert Brooke.

Discussion

1. Identity and Patriotism

"Dulce et Decorum Est":

Owen critiques the blind patriotism that sends young men to their deaths. The soldier's identity is stripped away by the horrors of war; they become “bent double, like old beggars under sacks,” a stark contrast to the heroic image of soldiers. Owen questions the societal narrative of honor in dying for one’s country.

"The Soldier":

Brooke idealizes the soldier’s identity, presenting him as a symbol of England’s values. His opening lines, “If I should die, think only this of me: / That there’s some corner of a foreign field / That is forever England,” reflect a romanticized vision of self-sacrifice and eternal unity with one’s homeland.

2. Innocence and Guilt

"Dulce et Decorum Est":

The poem portrays the loss of innocence through the lens of war’s brutality. The dying gas victim’s “froth-corrupted lungs” and “white eyes writhing in his face” reveal the grotesque reality that shatters youthful ideals. Guilt is an underlying theme, especially directed at those who propagate the "old Lie" of war’s glory.

"The Soldier":

Innocence is preserved and even glorified. The speaker feels no guilt, only a serene acceptance of his potential death as a noble contribution. The poem lacks the gritty realism of war, reflecting the early war optimism of 1914.

3. Loyalty and Duty

"Dulce et Decorum Est":

The loyalty in Owen’s poem is among soldiers themselves, evident in their collective struggle and suffering. However, the poem criticizes the misplaced duty imposed by a society that glorifies war while ignoring its devastating consequences.

"The Soldier":

Brooke’s poem celebrates duty as sacred. The soldier’s ultimate sacrifice is framed as an act of devotion to England, reflecting a sense of unwavering loyalty and pride in his nation’s ideals.

4. Courage and Compassion

"Dulce et Decorum Est":

Courage is implicit in the soldiers’ endurance of their horrific circumstances. Compassion is evident in the speaker’s vivid depiction of a dying comrade, aiming to evoke empathy and challenge the glorification of war.

"The Soldier":

Courage is entwined with the speaker’s serene acceptance of death. The poem exudes a quiet sense of bravery, stemming from the belief that his sacrifice contributes to a greater good.

5. Death and Humanity

"Dulce et Decorum Est":

Death is portrayed as agonizing and dehumanizing, stripping soldiers of dignity. Owen’s depiction of “the blood / Come gargling from the froth-corrupted lungs” is a stark reminder of war’s inhumanity.

"The Soldier":

Death is romanticized, envisioned as a peaceful, almost spiritual union with England. Brooke portrays it as a continuation of life’s purpose, not an end filled with suffering.

Conclusion

War poetry, as seen in these works, transcends being merely "anti-war" or "pro-war." It grapples with fundamental human experiences, exploring themes of identity, innocence, duty, and death. While Owen’s poem condemns war by exposing its horrors, Brooke’s work glorifies sacrifice through idealized patriotism. Together, they reflect the multifaceted nature of war poetry, offering both critiques and celebrations of its impact on humanity.

Compare Ivor Gurney's The Target with Wilfred Owen's Dulce et Decorum Est. What are some notable similarities and differences between these two war poets and their poetry?

Ivor Gurney’s “The Target” and Wilfred Owen’s “Dulce et Decorum Est” are poignant war poems that reflect the personal and collective suffering caused by World War I. Both poets served in the war, and their experiences profoundly shaped their work. Despite these shared experiences, their poetic styles and themes reveal notable differences.

Similarities

1. Shared Focus on War’s Realities

Both poems reject the romanticized view of war, focusing instead on its human cost.

In “The Target”, Gurney presents the internal conflict of a soldier grappling with guilt after killing another human. The soldier reflects, “Perhaps he was the only son,” emphasizing the personal loss that war brings.

In “Dulce et Decorum Est”, Owen highlights the physical horrors of war, vividly describing a gas attack: “He plunges at me, guttering, choking, drowning.”

2. Themes of Guilt and Trauma

Both poets explore the emotional aftermath of war.

Gurney's soldier is burdened by guilt for his actions, lamenting the moral ambiguity of killing in war.

Owen portrays a similar sense of helplessness and moral outrage, condemning those who glorify war as noble while soldiers endure unimaginable suffering.

3. Anti-War Sentiment

Gurney and Owen use their poetry to critique war.

Gurney’s poem underscores the emotional toll of war on individual soldiers.

Owen explicitly labels the patriotic ideal of dying for one’s country as “The old Lie,” challenging propagandist narratives.

4. Use of Realistic Imagery

Both poets rely on vivid, stark imagery to convey the horrors of war.

Gurney describes the haunting consequences of his actions, focusing on the psychological scars.

Owen’s sensory details bring the battlefield’s physical and emotional devastation to life.

Differences

1. Tone and Perspective

“The Target” adopts a deeply personal and introspective tone. The soldier reflects on his actions and their impact on himself, his family, and his victim. It is quieter and more reflective.

“Dulce et Decorum Est” is more visceral and confrontational, aiming to shock the reader with the gruesome reality of war. Owen’s tone is angry and accusatory, particularly toward those who romanticize war.

2. Focus of Critique

Gurney’s poem critiques the internal struggle of a soldier—the psychological burden of guilt and survival. His perspective is more humanistic, emphasizing individual suffering.

Owen critiques society at large, targeting those who perpetuate the glorification of war. His criticism is broader and more directed at cultural and political systems.

3. Style and Structure

Gurney: His style is simpler and more conversational, emphasizing the inner turmoil of the soldier. The structure is less formal, resembling a personal confession.

Owen: His style is more formal and structured, employing sophisticated poetic techniques like alliteration, enjambment, and pararhyme to heighten the intensity of his message.

4. Treatment of Death

Gurney: Death is a moral dilemma—killing is a personal burden that leaves lasting guilt. His poem is about the psychological cost of taking a life.

Owen: Death is a physical and visceral reality, graphically depicted through the suffering of soldiers. His focus is on the futility and brutality of dying for a misguided cause.

Conclusion

Both Gurney and Owen use their poetry to portray the devastating effects of war, but they approach this theme from different angles. Gurney’s “The Target” is introspective, delving into the moral struggles of an individual soldier, while Owen’s “Dulce et Decorum Est” is outwardly critical, addressing the societal glorification of war. Together, these poems provide complementary perspectives on the psychological and physical toll of war, challenging readers to confront its harsh truths.

Thank you